A common question I get is a variation on....
hey; the sail rig on the DUCKS and the other powerboats
you show with one mast looks weird; the mast is to far back. The
headsail luff is raked to much and the foot overlaps the side
of the wheel house so much it would need to be walked around when
tacking. You really think that rig will work?
No, of course I dont think it will work. Thats why I drew it on all the boats, spent hours working up the sail and rigging plans, and devoted a chapter to it in The Troller Yacht Book.....
To try to be serious.... I realize that sometimes when youre very close to a subject things seem clear to you but you dont explain them well, and by putting sails on these boats many people think theyre motorsailors and then think the rig is goofy because I guess I never made it clear they arent sailboats. A lot of thought went into that rig idea and heres what I was thinking.
1) The mast has to be aft of the house because if it is forward of the house (like Ive seen some modifications to the DUCK being planned), the boom will be to high for you to reach the sail easily, and the boom will strafe the roof of the house and take out antennas, lights, exhaust, and the radar when you change tack or need to swing it over. As designed, the boom doubles as a cargo hoist and with the mast aft the boom can easily be used for hoisting a skiff, motorcycle, or what-have-you to the back deck which is where youll likely carry things.. The boom is short and heavy. A friend used his as hoist to lift a small diesel out of a sailboat in the marina.
Is the mast to far aft to support flopper stoppers? I dont think so. I also think theres no need for floppers when you have the small main up except maybe in the case of big swells and no wind, a not unusual but still not common situation.
2) These boats are NOT sailboats. Yes, the hull type isnt much different from many old time working sailboats; if we lost the pilot house and lowered the freeboard some, we could make a sailboat. In fact, check out GULNARE shown in the Drawings & Photos section of this site. Shes essentially a DUCK, but built as a sailboat.
You could possibly call these Troller Yachts motorsailors, but that implies more emphasis on sail than they have. The larger ones, like EGIS and the others with two masts, could almost be called motorsailors although the sail area isnt much because I didnt want the expense or windage of having a serious sailing rig. So, as they are now, they still aint sailboats. I call this rig idea Sail Assist rather than Motor Sailor. Its not just semantics; its a different intended use than what is behind a boat that is actually a motorsailor.
These Sail Assist rigs have several functions.
A) Heaving too: The mast aft and the small main will serve as a riding sail. This will be left up at anchor holding the nose straight into the wind. If you want to fish, or, drift and sleep some night, the main will hold you into it. If you get in awful weather, the reefed main (and they all have 2 to 3 reef rows) will hold the nose into the waves. These are good things and almost unheard of with powerboats.
B) Sail Assist: The vast majority of your cruising will be, like with a sailboat, off the wind. Thats because its to damned uncomfortable to beat against the weather in any small boat, so, youll cruise on at least a reach, probably a broad reach actually. Ive never liked going due down wind if there are any seas because the boat rolls to much, so I tend to take down wind on broad reach courses.
This rig should be ideal here. The big headsail will balloon out and pull us along fine. Ive heard people say that it wont work because the angle of the dangle (the rake of the headstay) is to extreme. But, if you look at the two of the best examples of small boats planned solely for off wind use; the Arab dhow and the south pacific proa, what do you see but an extreme rake to the luff. The European square riggers were off wind boats too of course but those square sails are a first class hassle. In smaller boats designed for monsoon ocean sailing the Arabs had the right idea. Them and the south Pacific islanders would head out with the trades, sail and do whatever business they had to do until the season changed and the trades switched direction, then sail home again. They do need to do a little tacking in ports, but theyd tow their ship with rowboats in tight spots, just like we use our engine.
In fact, you CANT short tack with the sail assist rig shown. Somebody has to walk the headsail around the house. But at the risk of being repetitious, it was never meant to be able to short tack, the boat isnt a sailboat so theres no reason youre going to want to short tack, and the rigs Ive seen that try to make it look more like a sailboat dont do as well as this one will off the wind (and have the other failing I mentioned) which is the only time youll use it. The partial exception to what I just said is the Bubak Junk Modification youll see as an option (so far) on EGIS, ALCINA, and the 48 DUCK.
In stronger weather you can probably use sail alone, but, I likely wouldnt because the speed will drop. Again, these arent sailboats and the sail area isnt much to the displacement. Why sail at 4 knots when you can idle the engine and cruise at 7 or 8 knots with the sails up; 8 or 9 or more in the bigger boats. So instead of shutting down, Id throttle back until the engine is running at just a fast idle. This will make a major difference in the fuel you burn.
C) Emergency Power: Theres always the chance of your engine quitting, prop and shaft getting destroyed, fuel all draining out of the tanks, stopping the engine and finding ALL your batteries are dead so you cant restart it, or something else unlikely and strange but not impossible happening that stops your engine cold. In most powerboats if that happens youre out of luck.
Some boats rely on a second engine, but that still makes you dependent on this thing actually starting and doing its job. In between times you use it, and in practice you probably never will use it, you have maintenance on it. And of course the expense installing it in the first place. And unless it is a gen plant with a belt drive to the shaft, all it does ever after is sit there looking expensive and needing maintenance.
The belt off a small gen plant (and why do boat owners tend to get carried away there? We have 5KW wired into our house for when the power is out. It runs EVERYTHING except the dryer) is an inexpensive choice, but if what stopped you was a problem with the prop or shaft that wont help you.
You can carry a spare prop and puller and if youre feeling lucky about the chances of ol Jaws not being under the boat, you can switch props. But if the shaft is ruined your dead in the water.
Heres how easy that can happen, and luckily for me it happened right at a marina with a sandy beach I could have careened on if I had to.
Heading into the slip, I set my cocktail down and nonchalantly goosed her in reverse to quickly swing the bow to the left and stop. I was rewarded with a huge CRACK sound and . I threw the control into neutral as the boat kept going forward and banged into the dock. Odd. I tied up, then looked at the engine. I was sinking!
Heres what happened.
I hadnt paid attention to the bolts holding the shaft coupling to the engine, and 3 of the 4 had vibrated out. The last one had held, but, when I threw the control into reverse and goosed the throttle, the prop was pulling against the coupling, and the nut on the last bolt stripped and slipped but didnt come off. The shaft moved back 3/8 and was stopped by the nut but the lips on the two couplings that line them up were now not together. That meant when the engine rotated the one bolt in one hole of the shaft coupling became the rotation center. As the point was 2 or so above the CL of the shaft, something was gonna give. You wouldnt think a 5/16 hardened steel bolt would be so strong but it was able to bend the 1 1/2 prop shaft, and partially rip the stuffing box off the keel. This left a big area for water to come in.
I did an emergency patch on the leak by jamming cotton balls (my wife always has cotton balls for some reason) into the opening, than tore up an old shirt, rolled the strips into sort of a cord, and jammed them in using a hammer and screw driver as a caulking iron. I now carry caulking irons on any wood boat Im on. This got the leak down to a trickle and I was able to leisurely haul the boat. But I had to pull the shaft, have it straightened, remount the stuffing box and shaft log thing (it wasnt through a heavy keel but rather, bolted to the bottom of the hull; the boat was an old Chris I thankfully now dont own), re-drill the coupling holes since the threads were shot, find very skinny nuts to re-bolt the couplings together since there wasnt the room between the trans and the coupling for a normal nut.
In other words, if this had happened out in the ocean, and it could of; you see a bit of flotsam and stop to check it out, youd be dead in the water, and no belt drive to the shaft system would help you.
Anyway, feel free to put a more normal sailplan on the boats if you want. But think about what Ive said. I think it makes absolutely NO sense to put a sailplan on these boats thats designed for pointing, and, while not impartial, I really think the sailplan as designed is the best way to go.